The question is actually about honesty: is it ok to be brutally honest with your friends ?
I was asked to give my thoughts on the topic to Aquarius magazine for the upcoming June edition and decided to share them on my blog here.
My answer is: it depends on the situation.
Being brutally honest is not always a good thing. If you take an extreme example, like the denonciation during the nazi period, you can say it was then very harmful to be honest about your Jewish neighbour.
Honesty can sometimes be more harmful than lying.
In some circumstances, if someone does something kind for you for example, a dinner that does not taste good, you can still enjoy your friend’s presence without having to say that the food is not good, that would be unnecessary.
All truths are not good to say we say in French (“Toute verite n’est pas bonne a dire”).
The same goes with friendship.
What I think is important to remember in all relationship is HOW we say things. If being brutally honest means being rude, it is in general not helpful.
We do not want to hurt someone who is happy about his love life or a new dress by being rude. If that person is happy the way he is, you can enjoy the qualities that you appreciate about him or her without pointing out to what you dislike.
However, if being brutally honest means telling the truth with love and care, then it is different: in this case you have your friend’s interest at heart first and foremost and you may actually be “brutally” honest.
In any case, before saying something I find it considerate to:
1) ask permission; we are more likely to get the buy in and asking permission lets the other person feel involved and respected. She or he is more likely to listen to us if we ask them rather than if we just blurt our opinion out inconsiderately.
So for example, if we want to protect your friend from doing something wrong (he is with a girlfriend we think is not right for him and he is thinking about getting married), I would first listen and check if he is happy and then ask if I can give my honest opinion before I do so.
2) Not to diminish our friend or make him or her feel stupid or unworthy.
3) Suggest rather to impose opinions, and to speak for ourself: “I see you are not very happy with this person”, “you expressed doubts a few months ago”, “I am curious about how you are feeling now”, will get a longer way than just saying “your boyfriend is an idiot” (!); or this color looks amazing on you, you should wear it more often for example, versus “you look terrible in this dress”.
Bottom line: it is not ok to hurt our friend inconsiderately by just blurting any truths out but it is absolutely ok to want the best for our friend and to care. We should make sure that we are not being just brutal in our honesty, but that we are also being considerate and loving, otherwise our message will not be heard.












